Charitable Giving Is Trending Up. So Why Are Nonprofits Losing Donors?

Smaller nonprofits that rely on a limited number of donors have reason to be concerned about the latest national fundraising trends.
According to the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's Q2 2026 report, released in October:
Charitable giving increased 6.6% during the first half of 2026.
The number of donors declined 1.6%.
Just 2.9% of donors accounted for 76.4% of dollars raised.
Donors giving $1–$100 declined 4.2%.
More money is currently coming in, but it's coming from fewer donors.
What Does That Mean for Smaller Nonprofits?
For an organization with a modest budget, losing even a few consistent donors can create a significant gap. A shrinking base of support can be easily overlooked when a large contribution makes this year's fundraising results look strong.
With fewer supporters to help fill the gap, losing a major gift next year could create significant financial challenges. How much of your funding depends on a handful of relationships? It's an important question to consider as you develop your 2027 fund development plan.
7 Areas to Prioritize
Nonprofits of all sizes should be thinking about two things: strengthening the relationships they already have and bringing new people into their circle of supporters. Both deserve intentionality, even without a large development team.
Start with your donor history.
How many donors gave more than once? Who supported you last year but hasn't given this year? Are you consistently attracting new donors, or relying on the same small group? A review of your donor records can help identify relationships that may need additional attention.
Make stewardship part of your fundraising calendar.
Donors shouldn't hear from your organization only when you're asking for money. Share program updates, reach out personally, and show supporters what their contributions have helped accomplish. A phone call, handwritten note, or personalized email can go a long way.
Consistency is far more important than having an elaborate stewardship program.
Ask donors what excites them.
When was the last time you asked a supporter what drew them to your organization? Which programs interest them most? What would they like to learn more about?
These conversations can tell you a great deal about why people give and what keeps them engaged. They can also uncover interests, skills, and connections you might never have known existed.
Invite your supporters to open doors.
Some of your best opportunities to reach new donors come from the people who already know and trust your organization. Ask supporters if they know someone who might be interested in your mission. Would they introduce you to a friend, family member, or colleague? Could they help arrange a short presentation at their workplace, church, civic group, or community organization?
Make it easy for people to introduce others to your work without feeling responsible for asking them for money.
Give new supporters a reason to get involved.
Reaching new donors starts with giving people an opportunity to connect with your mission. Share a specific need, invite them to a program or community event, or offer a chance to volunteer and see your work firsthand.
Be clear about what their support can accomplish and give them an easy next step. Then follow up. A first donation or volunteer experience is an opportunity to begin a relationship.
Reconnect with donors who have stepped away.
Before assuming someone has lost interest, reach out. Share what's happening at your organization, ask what they've been up to, and invite them to reconnect. Some of those conversations may lead to renewed support.
Pay attention to your funding mix.
Donor retention and outreach are important, but so is reducing your reliance on a handful of contributions. Consider where individual giving, grants, sponsorships, and recurring donations fit into your broader fundraising strategy. Understanding your vulnerabilities is the first step toward addressing them.
Sustainability requires making relationships, outreach, and revenue monitoring when setting priorities for the coming year.
As you plan for 2027, don't stop at asking how much you need to raise. Ask who will be there to help you raise it.
Let's Strengthen Your Funding Strategy
From grant writing to funding strategy, Shared Ground Consulting helps nonprofits build a stronger financial future. Explore Our Services
Source: Fundraising Effectiveness Project, Q2 2026 Report. Figures reflect estimated giving trends through June 2026 among participating organizations and may not reflect every nonprofit's experience.
.png)



